The best fit I've found so far is Merrell Agility Peak. They have a glove-like fit and they are categorized as a cushioned shoe. They have a minimal drop of 6mm, and they have great traction in mud and snow. I don't get sore toes when pounding downhill for several miles. I have found them to be a little hard, though, so I am still looking. And maybe they're not hard; maybe it's just my feet and aging. All I know is the extensors on the top of both of my feet are sore after 18 miles on Chuckanut Mountain.
I ordered three new pairs of shoes a few weeks ago from Road Runner. As a VIP Family Member, I am able to try the shoes out on the trail and return them up to 90 days. The first pair, Innov8, didn't make it past the try-on stage. They are shaped strangely for my foot. The toes curve inward, and when I put them on, they cause my foot to roll aggressively to the inside, even when just walking around in my living room.
Pair number two I thought I was going to love: Brooks Caldera. They are springy and light, and they feel great on. I ran 20 miles on Chuckanut Mountain in them two weeks ago, and my foot moved all around inside them. My toes slid to the front when running even a slight downhill, and they nearly slipped off my heels when running uphill. I had to tighten them less than a mile into the run. In the end, I had sore toes and decided they are too wide for me. For someone with a wider foot, they would be wonderful!
Pair number three I am keeping; they are Brooks Pureflow, and they will be my indoor-only treadmill shoe. I'd been running in a three-year old model of the same shoe on the treadmill, so it was time for a new pair. They still have a wonderful fit and are super light. I also noticed they kept the same treads, which don't work very well for me running on the dirt road I live on. Little rocks from the gravel get lodged in the treads and then poke my feet. They would be fine for outside if I ran on paved roads.
After my long run this weekend in Bellingham, I visited Fairhaven Runners to try some shoes there. They brought out the newest Saucony Peregrine, which I have run in before, as well as Brooks Cascadia and Salomon Sense Pro Max. I ruled out the Nike pair and HOKAs because Nike never fits me right, and my toes catch on something inside the HOKAs. (I already have a pair that I love the cushioning in.)
The first one I tried was the Salomon. From the moment I put them on, I liked them, and they're what I took home with me. I liked the Saucony Peregrine, but they are a little narrow in the toe box and squish my little toes sideways. The Cascadia had a 10mm drop, which proved too much. I ran in the Salomons Sunday, and will again on trails with some decent climbs and downhill on Wednesday and Saturday.
I have a rule, that with each new shoe that goes into my running shoe bin, one pair must also come out to be taken to Goodwill. I'd better start selecting. Meanwhile, I need to get to Road Runner in Bellevue to return some shoes!